Two middle age business workers smiling happy and confident. Working together with smile on face at the office
Auditing

Three checks to test whether your Quality Management System works between audits

Published: November 12, 2026
Two middle age business workers smiling happy and confident. Working together with smile on face at the office
Auditing

An auditor spends a few days with your Quality Management System (QMS) each year. The system runs for the rest of it.

ISO 9001 certification tells you how the system looked during those few days. It tells you much less about the months in between, which is where the work gets done.

So if your QMS disappeared tomorrow, would anyone notice? Not because the paperwork was missing, but because the organisation became harder to run.

The theme for World Quality Week 2026 is Quality: powering performance. For a QMS, that means helping the organisation make better decisions, find problems earlier, and drive continual improvement. Passing the audit is the minimum.

Most established systems drift. Over time, maintaining the system becomes the job, procedures describe work that is no longer done that way, and quality activity peaks just before a surveillance audit. That is common, and it can be fixed.

The difficulty is that drift is hard to see from the inside. Documents are current, audits are scheduled, and the certificate is on the wall, so everything looks in order.

The gap only shows when you compare what the system says happens with what actually happens. That comparison doesn’t need a full audit. It needs a few well-chosen checks on how the system is really being used.

These three QMS effectiveness checks use records you already hold. For a small to mid-sized system, each should take an hour or two, and none needs new tools or outside help. You don’t need a perfect result. The aim is to find where the system and the work have drifted apart.

ISO 9001:2026 was published in September 2026 and replaces ISO 9001:2015. If you are certified to the 2015 edition, the transition period runs to 30 September 2029, so confirm your timing with your certification body. These checks suit either edition, and where the 2026 edition changes something relevant, we’ve noted it.


Check 1: Find one decision your last management review changed

Open the minutes from your most recent management review. Look for a decision that changed a resource, a priority, a process, or an objective.

If you find one, the review is doing its job. ISO 9001:2026 (clause 9.3.3) expects management review to end in decisions on improvement opportunities, changes to the QMS, and resource needs, so look for these outcomes.

The 2026 edition also changes what a review has to cover (clause 9.3.2). Changes in the needs and expectations of interested parties are now a named input, and the effectiveness of actions on risks and on opportunities are reviewed separately. If your agenda still follows the 2015 list, check that these items appear in your minutes.

If the minutes mostly show information being “noted” and the actions are about audit preparation, the review is being held for the clause rather than for the organisation. Other signs are a long agenda of reports, little recorded discussion, and the same standing items every time.

In a useful review, someone brings a trend, such as repeat complaints rising in one product line, and the group makes a call on it. The minutes show who will do what and by when, and the next review reports back on whether it worked.

Next step: Take one piece of performance data to your next review, such as repeat complaints or late deliveries. Ask for a decision on it, not just a report.


Check 2: See whether closed corrective actions have come back

Choose five corrective actions that were closed in the last 12 months. For each one, check whether the same or a similar problem has been raised since, in the same area or somewhere else.

A repeat usually means the action fixed the instance and left the cause alone. The person was retrained, or the document was reissued, but nothing in the process changed. ISO 9001:2026 (clause 10.2.1) requires you to review corrective action effectiveness, and this is a quick way to test it. Clause 10 is now shorter in the 2026 edition, with continual improvement moving from 10.3 up to 10.1, so update any procedures that still cite 10.3.

Pay particular attention to actions closed with training or a reminder email, as these are the most likely to come back.

A clean result is a good sign, if the closure record shows how effectiveness was confirmed, not just that the task was completed. Ideally, the action addresses the cause, someone checks a few months later that the problem hasn’t returned, and that check is recorded.

Next step: Reopen any repeat and keep asking why until you reach something in the process you can change.


Check 3: Pick one QMS measure and find out who uses it

Choose one measure your QMS collects, such as on-time delivery, customer satisfaction, or defect rates. Ask the person responsible what they do differently when the number moves.

If the answer is “nothing” or “I send it to the quality manager”, the measure is being collected but not used. ISO 9001:2026 (clause 9.1.3) requires results to be analysed and evaluated, and this is where many systems stop short. Either make the measure useful or stop collecting it.

The 2026 edition also separates the evaluation of actions on risks from actions on opportunities in this clause. If you only track one of them, your analysis may now be incomplete.

A healthy system has a small number of measures, each with a named owner, a target, and a known response. Five measures that people act on are worth more than thirty that fill a dashboard.

Next step: For each key measure, record who reviews it, how often, and what they would do if it moved the wrong way.


What your results say about QMS effectiveness

If all three held up, your QMS is connected to how the work gets done. Run the same checks each year to make sure it stays that way.

If one or two didn’t, you’re in good company. Fix the weakest first, and do it before your next surveillance audit rather than while preparing for it.

If none held up, treat it as useful information. It usually means the system was built for the audit and needs to be rebuilt around the work. Start with management review, because it sets the priorities for everything else.

Whatever you find, write down the issue, who owns the fix, and when it will be reviewed. Taking the results to your next management review is a good way to start, because it gives the review a real decision to make.


Certificates show reach, not value

Many organisations hold ISO 9001 certification, but a certificate can’t show how much value each one gets from its system. Only the organisation can see that.

A QMS is worth keeping when the organisation would struggle without it. These three checks show whether yours is there yet.


Your internal audit program is the next place to look

An internal audit that only confirms the procedures and records exist can miss all three issues above. An audit that tests whether processes achieve their intended results will find them.

That takes auditors who know where to look and which evidence to ask for. It’s a skill we teach at RTP in Becoming a Skilled Lead Internal/External Auditor, and it’s what separates an internal audit that adds value from one that only meets the requirement.

From the training room: Our trainers see the same drift when they audit. Claire Bingham’s advice is to document what you do, not what you think will get you through an audit. Micheal Martin suggests asking one question when you watch a task being carried out: how would this process occur without me in the room?

Find out more about our Becoming a Skilled Lead Auditor course  


Further reading

Find out how ISO 9001 drives quality, sustainability and customer trust
Read about quality standards beyond ISO 9001
Understand how ISO 9001 sets the global standard for quality management

 

Back to Insights

What our students say about our courses

“The virtual classroom coupled with an enthusiastic trainer made the course easy to run through and as good as any face-to-face courses I have ever attended.”

“Honestly thought it was gonna be boring. I was very wrong! Very engaging and informative. Loved all 5 days and will be back for more courses!”

“Let’s be honest – ISO standards aren’t exactly edge-of-your-seat material. But this course proved that with the right coach, even clauses and compliance can be compelling! Packed with real-world examples, well-paced sessions, and just the right amount of workshops, it was surprisingly enjoyable. Highly recommended!”

“It was clearly evident that the lead auditor trainer had significant industry-related experience in auditing. He was able to keep the class fully engaged with personal interaction and reinforce learnings. Getting full copies of the standards was amazing, the catering and the training location in Brisbane was perfect.”

“The trainer’s experience and real-life examples gave great context to the course material. The 5 days allowed the material to be digested in a way that was not overwhelming. I’d definitely recommend the course to others.”

Need help finding a course?

Speak directly with a member of the RTP team to decide which course is right for you.

×